I was delegate #50 in the rapid transit public meeting on June 1st, 2011 at the Waterloo Regional Council Chambers. It was an interesting experience to present at a meeting with such a wide variety of opinions, some of which are well-informed, and some that make you chuckle.
Later on, I found multiple comments related to my presentation on Twitter, and thought I should provide a response. I've listed a subset of five points from my presentation below, and quote the opposing tweets that relate to each one.
1. Regional Council is biased in favor of LRT.
"Uh! Bias or researched and decided it's the best choice! "@farwell570News: Delegate James Maaser...Suggests clear bias for trains."
Perhaps Cameron missed part of my presentation, but I did state that there has been a clear bias for trains
from the beginning—that is, many years ago, and long before any study said that LRT was a feasible option for Waterloo Region. In fact, even
after studies had shown that LRT was
not feasible, there were still Councillors pushing for these trains.
Essentially, Council kept doing different studies and throwing in different criteria, until they had a study that told them what they wanted to hear. They finally got what they were looking for with the Multiple Account Evaluation (MAE)
Report in 2009. And even this report states that BRT offers better value for the dollar:
"BRT Spurline performs much better overall than BRT King Street, and performs best of all the options on the ratio of transportation user benefits (those expressed in dollars) to project costs." (MAE Report Conclusions, p. 37)
In fact, LRT cannot be justified in Waterloo Region using
any standard cost/benefit analysis—it can only be considered feasible if other "non-traditional" factors are thrown in, hence the
"Multiple Account" Evaluation. The MAE Report describes itself as a:
"..framework capable of considering non-monetary and/or qualitative measures of benefits."
And it allows:
"..the consideration of factors that could not be considered in a traditional analysis;" (MAE Report Executive Summary, p. 2)
I don't know about you, but somehow this kind of language reminds me of the "non-traditional" financing we used to build RIM Park, and the "creative accounting" used by companies like Enron....
2. All of the money for LRT will be borrowed.
"Chair Wideman takes James Maaser to task for claiming all LRT funds are borrowed - explains $565 million come from upper levels. "
Amazing. And where, may I ask, are the upper levels of government getting this $565 million from? Do they have a special savings account in Switzerland set aside for this?
No. They are going to borrow it, of course. All of it.
And who will service this debt? The taxpayer, of course.
So if we do build LRT, then for the next ~20+ years every Canadian taxpayer—including those in Waterloo Region—will be paying for part of our LRT system, via federal income taxes. In addition to this, every Ontarian taxpayer—including those in Waterloo Region—will be paying for their part of our LRT system, via provincial income taxes. And on top of all this, residents in this Region will be paying for our part, via huge property tax increases (10%+).
Now let's consider the concept of a down payment. In the real world, we have to save money
ahead of time for a down payment before we can buy large assets such as a house, and the bank checks to make sure this money was actually
saved, not borrowed. In the real world, if you don't have a down payment then you don't buy a house—period.
Councillor Wideman believes that the (borrowed) money pledged by the federal and provincial governments is like a down payment for the LRT system. Apparently, our government finance departments are high on the same magic pixie dust that spawned the sub-prime mortgage market in the USA. But is this sustainable? Is this how the world
really works?
Imagine I wanted to buy a house, and went to the bank with my parents looking for a mortgage. Suppose I told the bank: "Now I don't actually have any money saved up for a down payment, and neither do my parents, but both my mom and dad are willing to borrow some money and then hand it over to me so I can use it as a down payment." Would the bank look favourably on this arrangement? Or would they consider me to be a high-risk, reckless borrower?
3. Talk is cheap, and it's easy to spend other peoples' money.
"Bad bet from James Maaser: asking room for volunteers to pay for #LRTawesome - hands fly up. Yes, some taxpayers like it!"
Yes, I'm sure it's true that there are some LRT supporters who would gladly donate 20 or 50 dollars to support the cause. Unfortunately, it would take over 5 million donations of $50 to achieve the estimated $253 million regional portion of LRT costs.
What I really intended with the question was this: how many LRT supporters would be willing to invest
significant money in this project? I'm not talking about 20 or 50 dollars here—that won't even buy you a toy train set. I'm talking about cheques for five, ten or fifty
thousand dollars.
The estimated construction costs for LRT work out to about $1505 per capita ($818M / 543,700). So, if we were to build this system with our own resources only, then every woman, man and child in Waterloo Region would have to cough up $1505. For an average family of four, this would equal $6020.
Would we be spending this kind of money if it came out of our pockets alone?
Of course not. But if we can weasel it out of other peoples' pockets, well that's a different story altogether....
4. Experience does count for something.
"James Maaser: young people haven't paid as much tax as me, and shouldn't be considered equally. / Yay! Bigoted agism."
Firstly, just for the record, I am currently 32 years old. It wasn't that many years ago that I was a college student myself, with no money and virtually no taxes to pay. Most of my friends are younger than me, and this is the age group I relate to best. And I am not prejudiced against young people.
Secondly, what I actually said in my presentation was this (paraphrased):
"A recent Metroline poll found that those who are most in favor of LRT are young people, who coincidentally happen to have the least experience paying property taxes. And those who are least in favor of LRT are older people, who coincidentally happen to have the most experience paying property taxes."
I did not make that statement to disparage young people. The point I was getting at is that experience often changes our opinion/perspective on things. And many things seem great at first (like impulse shopping with credit cards), until the ugly bill arrives and we have to pay with our own hard-earned cash.
Or consider this scenario: you are looking around to buy your first home, and you ask two of your friends for advice. Your first friend, a university student living in residence, advises you to buy the biggest house you can afford, since this offers you a better chance for the most profit (when you sell later on) and also gives you lots of room for a growing family. Your second friend, a retired neighbour living in their own mortgage-free house, advises you to buy a small house that is well within your budget, as this offers you the lowest operating costs and flexibility during the tough times, when money is tight. Let's assume that you find both opinions equally compelling. So whose advice should you follow?
In that scenario, where both opinions are well-reasoned and equally compelling, I would probably take the second friend's advice. Why? Because they also have experience on their side, which adds some weight to their argument. And most people would not consider this experience factor to be "bigoted ageism"—it's simply common sense. Experience
does count for something.
And the people here with the
most experience paying taxes are the
least in favour of LRT.
5. The majority of regional citizens are against LRT.
"James: To Regional Council - you all had a whipping in the last election on LRT! (Er... they got re-elected?)"
Assuming that voters are in favour of LRT simply because some Councillors were re-elected is incorrect for several reasons. Firstly, many of these same Councillors appeared to be opposed to LRT during the election campaign, and now are on the verge of breaking their election pledges. This
Record article sums it up well by saying:
"Most of the 12 politicians who will decide rail transit were elected last October saying they could not support the proposal at its estimated cost."
Another
Record article noted: "Statements by 29 regional council candidates suggest two-thirds oppose or lean against the $800-million plan to put electric trains on local streets."
Secondly, many people vote for incumbent politicians simply because they don't think there are credible (e.g. experienced) alternatives, or even because "the devil you know is better than the devil you don't".
Thirdly, there is a high level of voter apathy—particularly in municipal elections—and many people don't bother voting at all. They feel that it doesn't matter how they vote, because in the end Council will do whatever they want, regardless of what the majority of voters say. And wouldn't you know it, Council is poised to do just that in a few days time.
~~~